 |
In
this age of globalization it is not surprising that a number of
films deal with displaced persons in a strange land. Some have moved
voluntarily; some are fleeing impossible circumstances. Some live
in cultural ghettos; some are for the short haul (drug couriers).
Some reunite families. Some adjust well, and many are torn between
two cultures. For example Triple Agent
is about Fiodor, who fled the Tsar’s Russia to Paris in 1936.
He is accompanied by his Greek wife, Arsinoé. They live in
comfortable but mysterious circumstances. One day Fiodor and another
Russian disappear. The story has been adapted from a true story
by old master Eric Rohmer. It moves slowly. He
is “used to people comparing his films to watching paint dry.”
The costumes of 1936 were beautiful; many were originals from that
period. The crime which involved espionage was never solved and
the real wife died in a French prison for being an accomplice, although
she knew nothing.
Ken
Loach from Great Britain is a pleasant director. I was
impressed with his calm demeanor and fine suggestions at the panel
discussion on how to live with film critics (click here
for that article). He’s been in the film business for 40 years
and had such successes as KES, Raining Stones,
Ladybird, My Name is Joe, Bread and Roses,
and Sweet Sixteen. Therefore it is not surprising that
his film Ae Fond Kiss is also pleasant,
although the problem is serious. Casim is the only son of a Pakistani
family in Glasgow. He must endure long discussions with his Muslim
parents about their plans for his wedding with his cousin. His own
problems (his love for Scottish Roisin) prevent him from standing
by his younger sister who wants to move away to college. His older
sister’s wedding to the man of everyone’s choice is
endangered if Casim dishonors his family. Roisin teaches in a parochial
school where she must follow church dogma. She argues with a bigoted
Catholic priest and is soon without a job. In the end Loach sends
his multicultural couple off into the sunset to live happily ever
after together. This is a wonderfully made, humorous film with human
interest, and I’m not surprised that it won the first prize
given by the Ecumenical Jury. However, experience tells me this
is too optimistic. I thought of Romeo and Juliet, who, if both had
lived, would be arguing over the TV controls. A foreign critic asked
me for the German meaning of “fond” and I said liebevoll,
or at least more than nett. Do you agree? I had to look
up ae in the dictionary and it means one. Nobody had a
problem with kiss.
In
Beautiful Country, a G.I. returns to the
U.S. after the only mark he made during a stay in Viet Nam are memories
of his big feet and an Eurasian child, which is “less than
dust” in that country. The child, now a young man named Binh
(Damien Nguyen), moves away from his aunt’s
rural home to seek his mother in the city. We suffer with him as
he goes from work as a gardener for rich Vietnamese who down trod
their own people, to a refugee camp, to the hold of a ship carrying
illegal refugees. He loses his new-found mother and brother and
is hungry most of the time. On the positive side, he receives help
from a beautiful prostitute; he helps engineer a reversal of power
in the ship, and he finds the long-lost father living in a trailer
on a lonely ranch. We are left in the assumption that he will dedicate
his life to his father, who, so far, does not recognize this new
roommate because he is blind. Perhaps we should think that the former
soldier is as much a victim as the son. The idea behind the film
is a good one, considering that is it very true in many ways, but
it should have been shorter. Although it was almost a “medieval
odyssey” as the Norwegian director Hans Petter Moland
said, we didn’t need to know every detail. Nguyen is an excellent
actor, but not Eurasian. Think Tiger Woods or Keanu Reeves. He could
never convince anyone that he had a drop of Caucasian blood, which
he doesn’t.
Moland visited Viet
Nam in 1993 and loved it so much that he returned with his family.
During the press conference, Chinese actress Bai Ling
was confronted by a journalist speaking Chinese very quickly. The
simultaneous translators were stymied. We thought we were listening
to a political harangue. In the end Ling translated for us, saying
that the journalist liked her performance and was happy to know
that her career was progressing outside of China, from where she
had more or less been ostracized after appearing in Red Corner
with Richard Gere and also in The Crow.
Shouf Shouf
Habibi! by director Albert ter Heerdt
was a big hit in the Netherlands. Abdullah and his friends are young
Moroccans in Holland. They have no goals other than getting rich
quick (robbing a bank or becoming American film stars) and sex,
which is mostly imaginary since they have so far resisted arranged
marriages. They waste time making big plans in their cars or on
the phone. None of them will ever amount to anything nor will they
accept responsibility for themselves, although they feel called
upon to judge others. Abdullah’s brother has a respectable
job as a policeman and a Moroccan wife. He endangers the marriage
by falling in love with his female colleague. Abdullah’s sister
drops out of an upstairs window to meet her Dutch boyfriend who
is willing to be an accomplice in divesting her of an unwanted virginity.
The comedy is fast-paced with throwaway lines, but it’s all
been said before in East is East or Bend It Like Beckham
or aforementioned film Ae Fond Kiss.
Twenty-five
degrees is hot for a winter’s day in Belgium and unusual things
can happen. In 25 Degres en Hiver (25º in Winter)
we share this day with Spanish immigrant Miguel and his small daughter
Laura. He is a courier for his brother’s travel agency. He
is lucky to live in an era of mobile phones, because every time
his brother calls for a progress report, he is certainly just delivering
the tickets to the customer. Naturally, he’s not. Instead
he picks up a Ukranian woman named Sonia who has fled from the airport
immigrant holding center and runs into his mother (Carmen
Maura) who reports that his daughter is in the hospital.
Soon all four are seeking Sonia’s husband, whom she planned
to meet. There are episodes in an apartment, a senior citizens’
home, the travel office, and on the beach. Sonia finds her husband,
who was not expecting her and has been living with a Belgian woman
for years. As a parallel, Laura is homesick for her mother who moved
to the U.S. and never sends for them. It was fun to see Carmen Maura
again, that actress well-known from Almodovar films. French director
Stéphane Vuillet said he always wanted to
film in this familiar Belgian neighborhood. He considers Spain his
real country, which explains the flamenco soundtrack. Although the
film is quick and light-hearted, the topic of displaced persons
is serious. (BT)
In 1919 the Red Army
invaded Odessa, an historical reference for Trilogia:
To Livadi Pou Dakrisi (Trilogy: The Weeping Meadow),
the first of three films by director Theo Angelopoulos,
which begins with a large group of Greek refugees huddled in mud
flats surrounded by still water. They are all well-dressed in their
finest black and carry large travel cases. At the front stands a
middle-aged couple with two small children, a boy called Alexis
(Nikos Poursanids) and a little girl, Eleni (Alexandra
Aidini). Eleni was found by the family alone and crying
in exile, so they took her with them.
The
refugees build a new village on the flat, barren land, mooring their
small wooden boats nearby along the river. Alexis’ mother
dies and his father continues to raise the two children. As they
grow up together, Alexis and Eleni fall in love. Eleni becomes pregnant.
She is sent away by the village women to give birth to twin boys.
Alexis’ father plans to marry Eleni but she conspires with
Alexis to run away on the day of the wedding. Some musicians help
the young couple leave the village and Alexis finds occasional work
playing the accordion. Together they find their sons and take care
of them from time to time. They return to their old village for
the funeral of Alexis’ father. As Alexis, Eleni and their
two boys sit in the empty house, villagers throw rocks through the
windows. Night falls and the river waters rise. Alexis screams for
a boat to save his children. Someone leaves a boat which they use
to leave the drowning village forever. They return to the port city
of Thessaloniki from which Alexis eventually leaves for America
to tour with other musicians. He writes, promising to bring Eleni
and the boys to America as soon as he can. Eleni, however, is imprisoned
for supporting opponents to the current regime. The Second World
War breaks out, and Alexis sees that his only chance of reuniting
his family is to enlist in the American army. This is the beginning
of tragic losses for Eleni.
Dialogue is brief throughout
this three-hour film. Often just music and lingering looks suffice.
But the real beauty of the story lies in the composition: the landscape,
houses, boats, and moving music combined with the suffering etched
into the faces of the refugees. Every frame is a vision of astonishing
beauty, whether it depicts the funeral procession of boats gliding
silently with hardly a ripple on the surface of the lake or reveals
the brutality of war with brothers dead on the wet shores.
Director Theo Angelopoulos
has been making movies for over thirty years. His films are always
explorations of historical and existential subjects. You may recognize
bits of Oedipus Rex and Seven against Thebes throughout
the relationship between Alexis and Eleni. While shooting the film
on location in Greece, two villages were built from scratch. One
of about 100 houses, including a church and school, was built in
the dry bottom of Lake Kerkini. This village was swept away as the
water returned in winter, leaving barely enough time to shoot the
last scene. The shots of the exodus of the villagers are stunning.
Only a tree they planted remains standing tall in the middle of
the lake. The second village of almost 200 dwellings was constructed
like a terrace in the port town of Thessanloniki. Overall, they
are grand sets for a masterpiece of tragedy. (MW)
Competition
entry Country of My Skull is an adaptation
of South African writer Antjie Krog’s award-winning
novel about South Africa’s attempt to put its past behind
it using a Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) instead of
regular trials or war crimes tribunals. In a large departure from
the book, the film’s story is told from the perspective of
an American journalist (played by Samuel L. Jackson)
sent to South Africa to cover the hearings. While there, he meets
an Afrikaans poet (played by Juliette Binoche)
who is covering the hearings for radio. Their struggles to understand
one another mirror the larger struggle of the country, which is
trying to recover from the horrors of apartheid and somehow find
healing by confronting perpetrators with their victims.
Director John
Boorman faced a lot of challenges with the film, both beforehand
in securing the financing and afterward from critics who didn’t
like the addition of an American character or the romance that is
also a large part of the screenplay. However, from the viewpoint
of someone who knew very little about the TRC, I felt that the film
did a good job of showing the viewpoints and emotions involved in
rebuilding South Africa and finding a constructive way to confront
the violence of the past. Although the romantic elements seemed
a bit forced at times, they did add another dimension to the themes
of understanding and reconciliation. Overall, I thought the film
was rather inspirational, with great music and lessons that everyone,
from casual moviegoers to national leaders, should take to heart.
Hamburg-born
director M. X. Oberg presents The Stratosphere
Girl, the story of Angela (Chloé Winkel),
an 18-year-old European blonde whose passion for drawing manga-style
comics isn’t going to get her a job after graduation. On a
whim, she decides to take the advice of Yamamoto, a Japanese DJ
she meets at her graduation party, and go to Tokyo to find work.
Once there, she is quickly drawn into a strange and disorienting
world, where young European women live five to an apartment and
scratch out meager livings as hostesses, competing against one another
for tips. Even scarier, though, are Angela’s comics, which
spring to life and become animes in which she is the heroine. Soon,
she must finish sketching the story in order to find out whether
she will triumph . . . or possibly lose her life.
While the visual style
of Girl was very interesting and imaginative, and the idea
for the story was very interesting, overall the film didn’t
quite achieve its purpose. The melding of reality and comics was
difficult to understand, and the ending really didn’t make
sense. Perhaps the director went overboard on the feelings of disorientation
– the audience certainly experienced it with the main character,
but we never recovered.
Finally,
in a story of prejudices and their consequences, Israeli director
Eytan Fox’s Lalecet al Hamaim
(Walk on Water) follows Mossad agent Eyal (top Israeli
actor Lior Ashkenazi) in his attempts to find an
elusive Nazi criminal. Posing as a tour guide, Eyal accompanies
the German’s grandson Axel (Knut Berger)
on a trip through Israel where he visits his sister Pia (Caroline
Peters), who is living on a kibbutz. Eventually, Eyal’s
search takes him to Berlin, where he not only learns more about
the Germans he has grown up despising, but more about himself.
Lalecet does
a good job of demon-strating the role the past still plays in the
lives of young Israelis and Germans, for better or for worse. The
film not only touches on Israelis’ feelings about Germans
and vice versa, but also explores how the strained Israeli and Palestinian
relations may have grown out of reactions to the Holocaust. Although
the film’s ending is a bit over-the-top (and generated several
questions at the press conference after the film’s screening),
the acting is good, the scenery is interesting, and the themes are
universal. (KG)
|